Rate this book

Cnotliwy Książę (2009)

by David Starkey(Favorite Author)

3.93 of 5 Votes: 1

ISBN

8324134824 (ISBN13: 9788324134823)

languge

English

genre

History & Biography

publisher

Amber

review 1: Being one of the more recent Henry VIII biographies, and being specifically about Henry's youth, this was a popular choice when widespread interest became fuelled by 'that' TV series with Jonathan Rhys Meyers. I checked it for comparison with the 5 others I've read on Henry.I rate it on par with the good ones for dynastic background and incidental (impersonal) detail, but not for character study. If more drily and stuffily presented than personally accessible, this is academically fine and faultless in its fine detail.Not the first Starkey biography I've read, this is his pet dynasty. He specialised in Tudor history at Cambridge, writing a thesis on Henry VIII's household. His knowledge, as would be expected, is impressive, while his reader-connection is standoffish. This ... moremakes for a drier, less authentic result than I seek in any biography.Focusing on young Henry rather than his life, this might have been a more personal look at the 'spare' heir whose apparent destiny changed course for the better with the death of his older brother Arthur. No matter how meticulously researched and presented, personal supply inventories and monetary accounts do not suffice, in my mind, as 'personalisation'. Rather, a more intimate style of penmanship than Starkey's is the key.While, admittedly, generalisations can be invalid, the notary female historical biographers I've read (mostly, not all) have achieved more evocative results than their male contemporaries. Such women have been criticised for being overly emotive in approach and Starkey seems to be making a point around this in his own more remote, albeit supremely erudite, style. If, like me, you like blood pumped into a study's cheeks, tones given to their voice, rationale explained around their more private decisions, then Starkey disappoints. Only fair to consider that the 'heart and soul' we might be prospecting for in this has been reaped over and over from Starkey's most formidable biographical predecessors - there was no point in his aiming to replicate, but rather to find an original take on this weightily covered topic. In this unenviable task he succeeds, leaving his own hallmark on the vastly sprawling genre of Tudor biography.This slightly prickly addition to any Tudor reading shelf will contribute balance and sophistication.
review 2: David Starkey says of himself as a historian,"I write books as a storyteller. There is room for analysis, the inclusion of original documents and quite detailed reflections on sources, but the thing that holds the narrative together for me is the story." All of this holds true for "Henry: The Prince who would Turn Tyrant", which covers the period of time from Henry's birth to the arrival on the scene of Thomas Wolsey during the first year of his reign. Informative, entertaining and easy reading. less

Download links for: Cnotliwy książę

Advertising