Rate this book

Bunch Of Amateurs: A Search For The American Character (2012)

by Jack Hitt(Favorite Author)
3.38 of 5 Votes: 2
ISBN
0307393755 (ISBN13: 9780307393753)
languge
English
publisher
Crown
review 1: The larger thesis of this book - that amateurs matter - is great. The author has a good mixture of examples, from Benjamin Franklin as the quintessential example of American amateurs to modern "home-brewers" splicing yogurt genes. The slow, collective Internet-based debunking of the Ivory-billed Woodpecker sightings ruined my day. Not the most amazing non-fiction I've read, but very sociological and worth your time.
review 2: The prologue to this book makes it sound as if it is going to be a search into the heart of what being an amateur is, particularly in these days where new technology is offering so many opportunities for individuals to interact with - and sometimes go to war with - the officially sanctioned systems. Hitt announces that he's going to explo
... morere a specific facet of the American character, and explain what makes us a nation of experimenters.This is not that book.This is a series of longish essays clumped around a similar theme, and not any sort of rigorous argument. I get why the stories of the ivory billed woodpecker hunters are lumped together with the biohacker who is trying to manufacture glow in the dark yogurt in their apartment - but I don't think that those isolated examples say too much about what America as a whole is, nor do I think that they do much to paint a definitive portrait of what amateur-ness is.Which is not to say that the book isn't interesting or informative; it is. But Hitt's history as a contributor to This American Life makes perfect sense after reading this book, because that radio show tends t dance around it's themes without really pushing any strong conclusions one way or another, and that's more or less what Hitt does here. The difference is that I have lower expectations for an hour long radio show; I expect it to entertain me and inform me, but not necessarily exhaustively so. Books, however, are a different ballpark, and the same approach in a book format left me feeling like I'd read something kind of inconsequential.The material that is here is solid, and I enjoyed learning more about Ben Franklin and about Kennewick man. But I do feel like there's a longer more complete version of this book somewhere out in the ether which would be a lot more satisfying. less
Reviews (see all)
vick
Good stuff...very like Bill Bryson in a way as one story tumbles into the next.
chrissyawilliams
I'll never think of Ben Franklin the same again.
starling85
I'm in good company as an amateur. Fab read.
Write review
Review will shown on site after approval.
(Review will shown on site after approval)