Rate this book

1848: Year Of Revolution (2010)

by Mike Rapport(Favorite Author)
3.54 of 5 Votes: 4
ISBN
0465020674 (ISBN13: 9780465020676)
languge
English
publisher
Basic Books
review 1: I struggled with this book. As an avid reader of Victorian-era history, I expected to love it, but Rapport doesn't give us enough of a story line to hang his facts on. And he provides a never-ending flow of facts, details, and trivia. Partly the problem is the subject -- he's trying to cover Germany, with all its little states, Italy, with ditto, Austria, France, Hungary, the UK, the Baltic states -- and on and on. Each one of these countries suffered some sort of cataclysm during the 1848-49 period and Rapport provides us with a staggering level of detail about these events. It's all too much without a sense of the larger picture. Rapport will introduce a name of some obscure Austrian politician in one paragraph, give us two sentences about his views on a bill before... more one of the nascent political bodies, and then never mention him again. This goes on for page after page.Historians need to tell us the story as well as the facts, and Rapport falls down on the former while excelling on the latter.
review 2: I bought this book to learn about conditions in Europe that led some of our ancestors to head to America. It provides abundant detail on Austria-Hungary, the German states, and Italy among others. Although the book was only marginally helpful for my family history needs, it gave a fascinating picture of the growth of liberal political movements, professional revolutionaries, and national sentiment in the 19th century and the impact of the failure of the revolutions of 1848 on the shape of modern Europe. A well-written history! less
Reviews (see all)
Dorthy
And what did we learn from this, young idealists? Never send a liberal to do a socialist's job.
tjwdancer
A disappointment. Poorly organized and insufficiently edited for my taste.
Mitch
Really Interesting linking the events of this book to the modern world.
lala
This thing reads like a Middle Eastern newspaper.
Marina
Not too shabby.
Write review
Review will shown on site after approval.
(Review will shown on site after approval)