Rate this book

It's Really All About God: Reflections Of A Muslim Atheist Jewish Christian (2009)

by Samir Selmanovic(Favorite Author)

3.94 of 5 Votes: 2

ISBN

0470433264 (ISBN13: 9780470433263)

languge

English

genre

Nonfiction

publisher

Jossey-Bass

review 1: It took me a long time to finish this book. I bought it after I heard and was moved by the author's presentation at a conference in Washington DC. He is genuine and passionate about faith and commonalities between faiths. He has so many practical and inspiring insights that I underlined and dog eared that my copy looks pretty ragged now. Yet, I could only read through it in short bursts of about 10 pages at a time. And I'm not sure why. Sometimes the logic is circular, but that's not a problem in itself. The overhanging question of what to do with the exclusivity in the scriptures of Judaism, Christianity and Islam is far too quickly and unsatisfactorily passed over in the book's conclusion. But this is still a thoughtful and provoking work, and I expect to return to i... moret from time to time.
review 2: I don’t read much books on religion and faith (translated, that would mean none), partially because I barely possess any of each. Samir’s book captivated my attention by its subtitle “Reflections of a Muslim Atheist Jewish Christian”. Does such a thing exist, I had to ask myself. By birthright, I am Christian Catholic, baptized and confirmed, raised in a family that puts high emphasis on religious values and customs. Since I was a kid, I was taught that I’m supposed to respect other religions, but never cross the line. I was taught that this is the way it’s supposed to be, that “we” are better than “them”. Yet, it didn’t explain why I should keep at bay people I considered my friends. Because they belong to a different religion?That could barely convince me. If you teach me to believe in a God that loves all creatures alike, does that mean he doesn’t love my little friends just because they are Muslims/ Jews/ atheists?“Grace did not start with Christianity and it will not stop with Christianity.” p 71Reading Samir’s book was a great experience. He raises the question of religion vs. spirituality, stating that they don’t need to go hand in hand if it means religion is restraining our freedom to seek blessings in life. People are blessings. They expand and enrich our life. Yet, we are defined in our lives by what we are thought in our families and Sunday School groups.“We have come to the place where millions of people say, „Religious? No thanks. I'd rather be spiritual than religious.” But our departure from religion is at the very same time a departure from its rich treasures of community, insight, art, practice, organized action and hard lessons. Without religion, we find ourselves isolated, incoherent, and naive on our spiritual journeys.” p 16“It’s really all about God is another way to say It’s not really all about religion.” That’s what I find to be the thread line of this book. As a founder and Christian co-leader of Faith House Manhattan, an interfaith “community of communities", Samir promotes a new view on religion, one that accepts blessings of people of other religions and confessions. He calls for a “reformation” within three large monotheistic religions and atheism and strives to tear down walls that separate us. Coexistence is possible without compromising anyone’s dignity and beliefs. I find this to be necessary today, when our lives are inevitably influenced by “others”. Many of them are our good friends. Are we going to disdain them or accept that they can influence us for better? less

Download links for: It's Really All about God: Reflections of a Muslim Atheist Jewish Christian

Advertising