Rate this book

The Christmas Genie (2009)

by Dan Gutman(Favorite Author)
3.6 of 5 Votes: 1
ISBN
1416990011 (ISBN13: 9781416990017)
languge
English
genre
publisher
Simon & Schuster Books for Young Readers
review 1: So a meteorite hits a classroom and a genie pops out. He will grant the class one wish. The class tries to democratically select a wish by having everyone write their wish on a piece of paper and putting them in a container. The teacher pulls each wish out, reads it, and then the class discuss the merits of the wish. My 12 year old was thoroughly entertained by this book, and it was fun to read to her.
review 2: When a meteorite lands inside a 5th grade classroom, the students are surprised to find a rather irreverent genie inside. In gratitude for being freed from the meteorite, the genie grants the entire class only one wish. Each student writes a wish on a notecard and the rest of the book is a lively discussion of the pros and cons of each wish. There ar
... moree twenty-five wishes which, to me, seemed too many to cover but some of them raised some great ethical questions. I think Gutman had a great idea in using wishes (don't we all have a wish that we wish could be granted?) to get readers thinking about the ramifications of decisions. Overall, there wasn't much of a plot and the ending was, to some degree, predictable. less
Reviews (see all)
Maritza
This book is good for 5th graders and I recommend this book to people who like making wishes.
Delisa
Goofy fun with the extra added bonus of Santat illustrations.
Katrina1
Great read aloud for this season. My kids always love it.
Destinee
A quick fun read!
Write review
Review will shown on site after approval.
(Review will shown on site after approval)