Rate this book

Lumby On The Air (2010)

by Gail Fraser(Favorite Author)
4.07 of 5 Votes: 5
ISBN
0451230043 (ISBN13: 9780451230041)
languge
English
genre
publisher
NAL Trade
series
Lumby
review 1: I've read all the books in this series and when I saw this one, I was intrigued because it seemed much longer than the others. The story of the Walker's family reunion got a bit tedious but there were some humorous parts along the way. I must say, enough about the town's mascot Hank already. In the beginning of the series it was a cute device, but now it is just repetitive. And I really missed hearing more about the people of Lumby, as the plot centered around Marks really weird relatives. I don't think people are actually that moronic in real life - but then again, it is a novel. The general plot of Mark's brother in law, a Rush Limbaugh type, finding his soul at the end wrapped up rather quickly, but as it always does in Lumby, things turned out right in the end. I do lo... moreok forward to Gail Fraser's next Lumby tale though. I hope she sticks to the characters she's already created - the ones who live in town.
review 2: Pam and Mark Walker are celebrating their twenty-fifth wedding anniversary by inviting their families to stay at their bed-and-breakfast for a week. As in all families, there are some underlying issues that make the prospect of spending a week together a bit...interesting. Luckily, the county fair is in town that week, so everyone has plenty to do, if Mark can just make it through all the various competitions intact!What a sweet book! Just what I needed. This is the fifth in a series. I haven't read the others, but I picked up on the story with no problems.There were a few serious underlying ideas, like redemption, a teen's need to fit in at any cost, those family issues, and how the sale of a large tract of land to the wrong person can change a community's character forever. Linking all of these together was the question of how responsible we are to each other.Mostly this was just a nice story with repaired family relationships, a community that looks out for everyone, and Mark's crazy antics to lighten everything up. Seriously, who enters a chainsaw art competition when they've never done anything like that before? Overseeing it all is the town's mascot, Hank, a plastic pink flamingo who longs to be an eagle. I loved the newspaper excerpts! They added a perfect little taste of small-town life.I have to say that the resolution to the angsty teen didn't feel drastic enough. I didn't quite buy it. But the whole book is more of an escape than anything, so it did fit with the tone of everything else.I also could have used a cast of characters. I lost track of who everyone was. This is where it might have helped if I'd read the books in the right order, but my biggest problem was with the various family members. I got the feeling that they were mostly introduced for the first time in this book.I read an arc, but there was a whole section full of extras, such as recipes, discussion questions, and "What's in your..." interviews with characters. I enjoyed looking through all those.If you've had a rough day and you need to escape to a simpler place, pick this up. I'll be doing that with the earlier books in the series.Thanks to the publicist for sending me a copy for review. less
Reviews (see all)
cutie
A nice break from all of the fantasy, heart pounding YA and middle grade books I've been reading.
Andrealopez4161
Too formulaic and not nearly as charming as the other books in the series.
Zainab
cute silly fun family story with some dark untold stories
Marad
Excellent, Fun
Write review
Review will shown on site after approval.
(Review will shown on site after approval)
Other books by Lumby