Rate this book

Sherlock, Lupin & Me: The Dark Lady: 1 (2011)

by Irene Adler(Favorite Author)

4.34 of 5 Votes: 2

languge

English

genre

Historical Fiction

publisher

Capstone Young Readers

series

Sherlock, Lupin & Io

review 1: Sherlock fan here. I like the films. I like the TV shows. I like the literature. The eccentric Sherlock with his brilliant deductive skills are my cup of green tea. This book references the classic but puts a twist on the narrative using Irene Adler's voice to frame the story rather than Dr. Watson's. Irene was Sherlock's only love interest in Sir Arthur Conan Doyle's "A Scandal in Bohemia"; hence, when Irene claims to be Sherlock's only girlfriend she is referring to when they were adults in the original classic. This story isn't a romance, although the boys are intrigued by the unconventional Irene. The focus is on the developing friendship of Irene, Sherlock, and Lupin; three teenagers solving a murder mystery. The first person point of view makes it easy to understand ... moreand the Victorian illustrations and backdrop add flavor to the setting. Suspense abounds in this fast read.American Irene Adler is on vacation in Saint-Malo, France when she meets Sherlock Holmes. She is stifled by the Victorian rules regarding female behavior and it makes her rebellious. This might get lost on the reader as the author doesn't go into depth but only mentions it in the first chapter that frames the story. Irene just thinks about how the butler is telling her to be like a lady and later we see that she does not get along with her mother. Irene consistently bucks conventions saddled on women as the boys don't expect her to do anything dangerous or throw any punches. She surprises them in many different situations and exposes her untraditional ways.Sherlock and Irene immediately have a battle of wits before she convinces him to help her escape from the Butler that is looking for her. A juggernaut of adventures ensue that made me read the whole book in two hours. Their escape takes them to a boat owned by Sherlock's friend, Arsene Lupin, and the three flee to an empty mansion. All three use the place for a break from the pressures at home and to be independent. On the way back they find a dead man on the beach with a note in his pocket and follow the clue. The two boys try to protect Irene but soon find out that she is perfectly capable of protecting herself. Or her butler is. They invite her over for boxing lessons showing how they view her as an equal. This is quite progressive for Victorian times and the spunky Irene enjoys the freedom. The twists and turns of the mystery had me baffled and the resolution was satisfying.Irene's parents do not get along particularly well and we discover that Irene adores her father and resents the substitute butler at times even though he genuinely cares for her. After he gets her out of some scrapes and she calls him by his first name, she shows a slow maturation as her respect for him grows and she realizes that he does care for her. She does not understand her mother's lack of intellectual curiosity and later we learn that she is an orphan. She's punished for her impulsive behavior, but it has no effect on her because she doesn't value her mother's opinion and her curiosity for the world overrides her fear of authority. She's not going to be a Victorian woman that is happy in the domestic sphere. She's a feisty intellectual that is rebellious and has power struggles with her mother and butler. While the butler makes some inroads with connecting with her, the mother does not. The father making faces in boring social arrangements setup by the wife shows a certain disrespect to his wife and encourages Irene in her rebellious actions. He models some of the behavior seen in Irene. This dynamic makes for an authentic family and great discussions.If you like middle grade murder mysteries try, "Three Times Lucky" and "The Dead Man in Indian Creek." If you want twists on the Sherlock Holmes classics try: "The Case of the Missing Marquess" (Enola Holmes Mysteries #1) by Nancy Springer or "The 100-Year-Old Secret" (The Sherlock Files #1) by Tracy Barrett.
review 2: I appreciate very much having a mystery in the Holmes genre that is written from the point of view of a girl. I wish I could understand her motivations for being a bit bratty, though. Irene Adler is vacationing in a small seaside town in France. She gives her butler/bodyguard the slip in order to explore and meets a most unusual boy. It turns out this is the young William Sherlock Holmes. She calls him Sherlock to be contrary, as he says that everyone calls him William when he introduces himself. They banter and impress each other, begrudgingly, with each other's observation and deduction skills. Later, they head to the beach to meet Sherlock's friend, Arsene Lupin. It isn't long until these three discover a mystery that needs solved in the form of a body on the beach. They find a man wearing gentleman's clothing and many stones in his pockets along with a note that speaks of guilt. Irene sees a dark figure watching them from a distance. Who is the man? Was he murdered or was it suicide? Who was the dark figure watching from afar and did they have anything to do with the man's death? Fans who have already read Holmes stories will know who Miss Adler is, and there may even be a few out there who also know the Gentleman Thief, Arsene Lupin. This children's book is interesting with some suspense, but is much richer for those who already know the characters and their "future." So it's difficult for me to say if this is a better children's book that introduces you to these wonderful characters written by authors long ago or if it's a minor addition to the rich stories already in existence for those who are familiar with the works. less

Download links for: Sherlock, Lupin & Me: The Dark Lady: 1

Advertising