Rate this book

Coming Of Age In Second Life: An Anthropologist Explores The Virtually Human (2008)

by Tom Boellstorff(Favorite Author)

3.53 of 5 Votes: 3

ISBN

0691135282 (ISBN13: 9780691135281)

languge

English

genre

Nonfiction

publisher

Princeton University Press

review 1: This is a bizarre book, not for its subject matter but for the degree to which Boellstorff seems intent on reproducing Margaret Mead's approach to Samoa--treating Second Life as a bounded cultural isolate, worthy of understanding in its own terms. Given that the man's partner, Bill Maurer has presided over the death of language, this sort of almost positivist unreconstructed Boasianism is not a little surprising--maybe they have a Jack Spratt and spouse thing going on when it comes to high-flown post-humanist theory. Anyway, this focus produces interesting "ethnographic detail" but precludes a focus on the interlinkages (and crossing of boundaries between field and non-field or virtual and non-virtual) that made Samoa and make Second life such messy, interesting phenomena.... more Ironic that a book that's going to be being read in anthro intros in 2064 is such a missed opportunity. But then, its prototype remains evergreen despite its elisions.
review 2: Before I read Boellstorff, I registered for Second Life and spent a few hours in the last week just to see what it was about. I remain absolutely clueless. I'm trying to imagine what real life circumstances would attract me to spending any significant amount of time in this world, and I suppose I can think of a few. If I were confined to a bed, socially isolated, or stuck in a truly miserable job with plenty of free time at my desk, or if I wanted to have a virtual affair, I suppose Second Life would offer something. But my experience in a few hours (very limited, to be sure) is that it is possible to carry on mind-numbingly awkward "chats" with outlandishly curvaceous and lightly clad avatars. I have found these conversations to be just as awkward as I might find any conversation with a friendly random person who seems to have left some of her clothes at home or who is returning from a Renaissance fair in sparkling high heels. I have nothing to say after a few minutes, and neither in my experience do they. We share a virtual space and a few moments of mutual curiosity drifting off into boredom, until one of us blissfully teleports to another world. Well I suppose THAT is an advantage of Second Life. When the conversation slows, you hit a button and the people you are talking to just vanish. But why spend time in a world whose most interesting characteristic is an easy escape from the vapid and boring conversations that it otherwise offers? If you get serious about Second Life you can buy property and build objects and sell stuff and decorate your avatar with fancy skins... and then you can hang around in your fancy skin and still have boring conversations with people. But while wearing really cool virtual clothes! Am I not getting this? I am not getting this. Yes, I gather that virtual sex is a pretty big part of Second Life, and you can see the possibilities. Maybe that is what people are really doing in Second Life. I haven't gone there, so I can't say.Boellstorff treats Second Life as its own culture. He gives it a serious anthropological once over and does a good job of it. If you care about Second Life, this could serve as a theoretical, but also practical, introduction to the norms and habits of the world. It seems to be a little dated however. I've also heard that Second Life is not quite the hot property or hot world that it was a few years ago. But the best way to explore Second Life is just to sign up and poke around, and I don't regret doing so. I suppose I can imagine life circumstances where it would be a wonderful place to go. I'm just not in those circumstances. less

Download links for: Coming of Age in Second Life: An Anthropologist Explores the Virtually Human

Advertising