Rate this book

L'istinto Di Narrare. Come Le Storie Ci Hanno Reso Umani (2014)

by Jonathan Gottschall(Favorite Author)
3.63 of 5 Votes: 4
ISBN
883392467X (ISBN13: 9788833924670)
languge
English
genre
publisher
Bollati Boringhieri
review 1: Excellent book - interesting thesis, and well-written. Gottschall argues that storytelling is innate; humans evolved to tells stories because it helped both the individual and the group to succeed. Stories lend coherence and meaning to our lives. Stories simulate the problems we face, and allow us to practice the key skills of human social life. Stories are universal across cultures. Stories are not about happy things; in fact, they are usually about some of the more serious problems we humans face. Almost all fiction has a protagonist struggling to deal with a predicament involving some kind of anti-social behavior. thereby steep us in the norms and values of our culture. Stories are more "truthy" than true - that is, they present events in a way that gives them a meaning... more that overcomes helps the protagonist resolve the dilemma they were confronted with.
review 2: I decided to read this one because I've been trying to make sense of all the seemingly useless traits that are ubiquitous in human cultures. Why do we make up religions, confuse our children with absurd stories about talking animals when they have so much reality to learn, waste time and energy creating enormous monuments, etc.? Have these things actually been a benefit to humanity or is their prevalence just the result of cults consistently killing off the more rational, less violent competitors? Are these elements of our cultures that we take pride in really just leading us closer to the edge of a cliff with each new generation? It's interesting to think about, and so far nobody's really put together a totally convincing theory. This book does a pretty good job explaining the most likely reasons that scientists have come up with so far. I just think the conclusions he draws from these ideas are a bit off. And I found his analysis of conspiracy theories a little irritating. Yes, Alex Jones and David Icke are idiots. Not everyone who questions 9/11 and other controversial events are in their fan clubs. He also thought it was crazy to believe the government would spray chemicals on minority neighborhoods. Well, google "St. Louis sprayed with radioactive particles." That was a mainstream news story. Governments do horrible things all the time. A few years ago Hillary Clinton had to apologize to the people of Guatemala on behalf of U.S. scientists who secretly infected them with syphilis. Then their president, a U.S. backed dictator, was found guilty of genocide. Again, this is mainstream news. It just irritates the hell out of me to always be compared to the reptilian alien crowd for acknowledging that America isn't all about freedom and democracy. Based on some of the other things this guy had to say I feel like he really should know better. less
Reviews (see all)
ammonit43
Another problematic book to review. There is at least one factual problem. Mr. Gottschall argues the Holocaust was the worst genocide in history---wrong! Both the Stalin and Mao genocides were worse [20 million and 12 million respectively]. Fact checking is very important and easy today. Not getting something as simple as this correct is unforgivable and demonstrates a laziness. The other problem I had with Mr. Gottschall has to do with his attitude toward experimental fiction specifically and literary fiction more generally. For example: “Experimental fictions like Finnegans Wake are still in print, but they are mainly sold either to cultured autodidacts dutifully grinding their way through the literary canon, or to college students who are forced to pretend that they have read them”. It is as well this was said in a book; if it were a bar we’d be taking that out back. Mr. Gottschall doesn’t quite get the difference between cultural and biological evolution and doesn’t understand the nature of experimental modernism at all. True postmodernism is more or less gimmicky crap but the great works of literature that have challenged our sense of place and reality go far beyond this—Tristram Shandy, Finnegans Wake, The Mahabharata, Proust, Kafka’s oeuvre, and the list continues. The books that last, are often the books that challenge our sense of story and then take us deep into character, style, and ideas. This is where literary fiction truly shines but is not fit for mass-consumption. Because of this and other failings Mr. Gottschall gets 3 out of 5 stars.Fair entry position for understanding the nature of homo fictus [fiction man].
Mickbear
I've read a number of books about story, and what it means to us as human beings, including Yorke's Into the Woods and The Seven Basic Plots by Christopher Booker, who has a nice Jungian spin on it all. But this short volume by Gottschall is the best of the bunch by a country mile. Not only does Gottschall present the most convincing arguments for our addiction to story, he does so in such an entertaining way that you want to savour each sentence. And that last chapter actually scared the living bejesus out of me - I hope to god he isn't right.
Solange
an enjoyable read. Didn't realise how important stories are to us - the human species.
Elfy
No new material. Photos detracted from, rather than added to, the book.
pookiedgirl
Awesome Book!
Write review
Review will shown on site after approval.
(Review will shown on site after approval)