Rate this book

Shaman (2013)

by Kim Stanley Robinson(Favorite Author)
3.57 of 5 Votes: 4
ISBN
0316098078 (ISBN13: 9780316098076)
languge
English
publisher
Orbit
review 1: If you liked "Clan of the Cave Bear" and its sequels, you will enjoy Shaman. Shaman is the story of Loon, reluctantly being trained as a shaman by Thorn, whose nature is as prickly as his name. Loon is a fully-developed character, and it was interesting following his life with his clan, starting from a two-week "wander" survival test in the woods. I don't want to give away the arc of the story, so I'll stop here.This would have had a 4-star rating if the author had not chosen to use incongruous language such as "Mama mia!" for his ice-age characters' conversation.
review 2: Being the second offering by Robinson I read after the Mars trilogy, which I loved, I went into this with my expectations perhaps not lowered but certainly curtailed, so as to not be dis
... moreappointed. That served me well as otherwise I might have overlooked this book's fragile beauty.That's not to say it had no flaws. In fact, I agree with reviews that critique devices like the oddly chosen words, at times from other languages, for sexual terms, the seemingly random interjections of other perspectives, or the plotting and pacing, which certainly do not move as expected. And though I understood the limitation of seeing most of the story through the eys of a young male character, I would have enjoyed a female perspective now and again.But all of this belies both the beauty of the writing and the scope of the story which is ultimately somewhere just shy of mythic. The descriptions of landscapes of untrammeled and immense beauty, of bodily sensations from hunger and pain to the ecstasy of sex and good food, of animals and of paintings of animals, of weather and cold and heat and insects and fire; lots of fire - in short of most everything I could think of that might occupy the mind of a being intently focused on surviving at almost all times.As for the mythic scope of the story, here is where the book works or doesn't for you. One review I read argued that the society described would be riddled with superstition - curiously absent from this story. I'd argue that by eliminating the rampant superstitions that might have pervaded an existence like that of the humans in this book, the story conveys a Campbell-esque metamythology where story and the form of the story matter more than the details of the plot. There are echoes of their real life in all their tribal stories, and the tribal stories are mirrored by real life.For me, this worked admirably, but it's not for everyone. less
Reviews (see all)
Sid
Shaman deserves to be recognized as a classic. I look forward to reading it again someday, and maybe again after that. It has only two shortcomings. First, the narration is so focused on the processes underlying day-to-day survival that at points the descriptions of flint knapping and carcass carving and marching in snow shoes become tedious. And, second, the narrator, the Third Wind, as an elemental presence, relies on a prose style that's both measured and often beautiful, but it fails to register much urgency or generate much suspense.Nevertheless, from the first pages when Loon, the young shaman-in-training, sets out on his "wander," for which he's stripped naked and sent off into the frozen wilderness to make good or starve to death, the story transcends its premises, and Robinson's characters breathe with real life. This isn't a story about European hunter-gatherers trying to survive the Ice Age; it's a coming of age story about Loon, guided by the irritable and irascible older shaman Thorn. The women characters stand mostly at a distance, but a couple of them, Heather, an old medicine woman, and Elga, a foreigner who captures Loon's heart, are perfectly compelling even in their small doses. The neanderthals in this book make only casual appearances, with one exception--and this character, who the humans call Click, is one you'll never forget. Much of the plot is standard rite of passage fare, but several of the scenes have a haunting quality that's like nothing else I've ever read. Even if I never read Shaman again, I'll be taking parts of it with me wherever I go into the foreseeable future.
avneet101
Audiobook. I find listening to audiobooks is a different experience than reading the text. Kim Stanley Robinson is a master of description of geography, ground, terrain, flora, and for some this gets a bit boring. With the audiobook one can let the poetry of the words roll over oneself without getting too fussed about absolute visualization of the details. Here, the book reader is great and Robinson's natural care and love for his characters shines forth, creating a really pleasant experience.
Mmm
Wow! loved it.
Write review
Review will shown on site after approval.
(Review will shown on site after approval)